We're comparing EOS with Holacracy because we want employees to make more decisions. How do we tell which approach fits the authority we're willing to delegate?
Start by agreeing on the authority you actually intend to delegate, not by choosing the system that sounds most empowering. Clear responsibilities and distributed authority are related, but they are not the same decision.
EOS puts substantial emphasis on people, roles and team alignment. Its Accountability Chart helps clarify the major functions of the business and who is accountable for them. That does not, by itself, define every spending limit, approval right or decision an employee can make independently.
If you are considering Holacracy for its approach to distributing authority through defined roles, compare that governance choice with the leadership structure you intend to retain under EOS. Do not assume the two approaches make equivalent promises about who can decide what.
Before the EOS 90-Minute Meeting, write down three decisions that currently require the owner's approval. For each, specify:
- Who you want to make the decision.
- What boundaries they would work within.
- What would happen if the owner disagreed afterward.
Ask the presenter how EOS would support those arrangements and what your team would still need to define. Put the same scenarios to a knowledgeable Holacracy practitioner.
Choose based on the decision rules you are prepared to honor. If the owner intends to retain broad veto power, acknowledge that openly. No operating system can create meaningful delegation while leadership quietly reverses decisions people were told they could make.
Category: EOS vs. other operating systems