Our business coach already knows us well and offers to lead EOS internally. Should we use them or hire an EOS Implementer?
Evaluate the assignment separately from the relationship. Knowing your business is useful, but it does not establish that your coach can guide EOS implementation or challenge the leadership team objectively.
The choice is not simply between a familiar advisor and an unfamiliar one. It is between different capabilities, responsibilities, and potential conflicts. A coach who helped design your current structure may find it harder to question that structure. An internal leader can face the same problem when facilitating decisions about their own responsibilities.
Use the 90-Minute Meeting to understand what an EOS Implementer would contribute, then compare that with your coach's proposed role. Ask both:
- How would you help us move from understanding EOS tools to consistently using them?
- How would you handle a discussion that challenges your previous advice?
- Which decisions and follow-through would remain with our leadership team?
- What relevant implementation experience would you bring?
Do not assume your coach lacks the necessary experience. They may also be an EOS Implementer. Equally, do not treat general coaching experience as interchangeable with experience guiding EOS implementation.
My recommendation is to choose the person whose experience and independence match the work. If you retain your coach and hire an Implementer, define their responsibilities clearly. Complementary support can help, but competing guidance about how the company should operate can undermine the structure you are trying to build.
Category: Self-Implementing vs. Hiring an Implementer